Keith Gessen’s new Vanity Fair e-book, How a Book Is Born: The Making of “The Art of Fielding” (available for Kindle and Nook), is a thorough and riveting study of books and their business, and anyone with an interest in writing should do themselves a great favor by buying it right now. It’s $1.99 well spent.
But what is How a Book Is Born? To answer that, you should first know about The Art of Fielding by Chad Harbach, the novel that Gessen follows from its conception in Harbach’s head all the way through to its publication. Harbach’s book takes place at a small liberal arts school and is about, among other things, baseball. But what it’s about, according to Michael Pietsch, Little, Brown’s publisher and editor, is “perfection, striving, youth. It’s about those years when your job is to learn everything you can learn and try to understand anything you can understand, to try to study literature, and philosophy, and figure out who you are, and who you might become.” Little, Brown is doing everything it can to position Fielding as a Great Book (putting it first in their catalogue; Pietsch, David Foster Wallace’s editor [including The Pale King], personally overseeing it), and it seems to be working. The book, which was released September 7, has climbed into Amazon’s Top 20 (and now has a one-week wait).
Gessen (author and co-founder of literary magazine n+1) is a close friend of Harbach’s, and write about seeing Fielding in its early form, including as an excerpt that Harbach used to apply to MFA programs, and as a submission he gave to a workshop of a small group of friends. This is the chronological beginning of Fielding‘s path to publication, but along the way, the e-book outlines every step the book went through in the run-up to its publication, and the result is totally engrossing.
Through straightforward, incisive prose, Gessen tells us about book cover designers (and how the challenge was to not reference baseball on the cover); agents and editors, and their relationship to one another and their relationship to authors; the agony and danger of revision; the agony of rejection; the bidding war for the rights to the book ($665,000 was the winning sum).
What makes all of this so compelling is simple: Harbach’s story is just exciting to read. Gessen jumps from one aspect of the industry to another, casting people like Chris Parris-Lamb (agent) and Keith Hayes (cover designer) like principal players in a tightly-wound ensemble narrative, taking time to describe “aquiline” noses and ping-pong affinities. The scope of the story is dizzying; Gessen uses a plate-spinning narrative style–he’ll tell you about one cog in the machine and then run over to another before you have time to get bored.
And just having these well-rendered personalities would be enough, but Gessen also spends ample time describing the publishing industry in general. He gives time to its economics and its traditional structure, and then he points out all the ways in which these things are changing or are being threatened (the main threat is–you guessed it–Amazon).
The value of Geffen’s e-book is its breadth. For anyone with an interest in writing and/or publishing, no matter which aspect, you’ll find a solid foundation of information in How a Book Is Born. You’ll learn things like how indie booksellers have more influence than ever before, as well as being provided with huge amounts of relevant figures (agents can receive 70 queries per week; acquiring editors get 10 agented submissions per week). It’s not exactly groundbreaking journalism, but the piece is full of information anyone outside the industry (and many within) would find useful. Coming from an MFA background, I can personally tell you that aspiring young writers are significantly under-educated about the business side of publishing. An article like this should be required reading. And, it counts for something that all this information is in one place and is delivered in such a captivating way.
At 17,000 words, Gessen’s article is long-form journalism done right (something the publishing industry is starting to figure out how to do well with the e-book format)–it’s long enough to bury you in its story but also short enough (and told briskly enough) that it is never boring. Its overall message: content is king. For all of the brisk narration Gessen engages in, and for all the uncertainty creeping into the publishing conversation, it still comes down to the fact that people want to read good books. And Gessen’s piece is a really good article about a good book.


Well, the description sounded good so I downloaded the e-book and was disappointed.
“It’s overall message”
Seriously?
I read the article, in real print on real paper in “Vanity Fair.” How about that! It is a very good article, that’s true, and provides valuable insight into the current state of the publishing business. I also agree it should be read by anyone who is aspiring to publish a book by traditional means. I found it a little short on non-traditional publishing, so I hope Mr. Gessen might do a follow-up piece focusing on that aspect of the business. I also thought it was about 2,000 words too long. All that “fluff” at the end seemed a little off-message. Sorry to be a bit “snarky.” Really, it is a valuable piece, and it should be read.
Phil,
I agree, the piece slows a bit at the end, especially when he writes about Harbach’s home. It felt like he wasn’t sure how to end the article (and the last sentence was particularly mystifying). But I’m glad you liked it and, I agree, a sort-of companion piece about non-traditional publishing would be a welcome addition.
Great blog post Gabe. Gessen’s e-book pairs together two great themes: the hardcore reality of the book business past and present (the unglamorous daily stuff of acquiring, editing, sales, marketing and the transformation of book publishing by digital) along with the powerful publishing mythology around the tale of the much rejected but brilliant novel finally discovered (usually by some lit visionary, in this case a young agent), recognized as a literary masterpiece and swept onto bestseller lists.
Gessen’s piece pairs these two contradictory narratives to create a window into the reality of publishing while enticing the general reader with a fantasy, but a fantasy that the public and even publishing pros all love: the Literary rags to riches tale. Of course all publishing pros can cite stories of much rejected authors who finally hit it big, or just hit it at all, despite the fact that as Gessen says, its atypical. Most books don’t make money and lots of literary masterpieces, or just good books, languish unread if not unpublished.
But Gessen’s combination of these bookish archetypal themes makes for a great read and an even more engaging overview of the busines of books. And it was a Great idea to release it as an e-book. Kudos Gessen, Vanity Fair and, of course, Chad Harbach.
Thank you for this! The publishing industry is such a fascinating one and to have your approval just gave me the green light to buy it. Thanks!